AtlatestRepositorysigil-quic
sigil-quic / tree / testtest-quic-conformance.sgl
1
(import (sigil test)2
(sigil crypto)3
(sigil quic bytes)4
(sigil quic wire)5
(sigil quic error)6
(sigil quic frame)7
(sigil quic packet)8
(sigil quic connection)9
(sigil quic tls)10
(sigil quic tls codec)11
(sigil quic tls messages))13
(define ql6-original #u8(1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8))14
(define ql6-client-id #u8(11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18))15
(define ql6-server-id #u8(21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28))16
(define ql6-other-id #u8(31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38))18
(define (ql6-wipe! bytes)19
(when (bytevector? bytes)20
(do ((i 0 (+ i 1))) ((= i (bytevector-length bytes))) (bytevector-u8-set! bytes i 0))))22
(define (ql6-wipe-events! events)23
(for-each24
(lambda (event)25
(when (eq? (tls-event-kind event) 'secrets)26
(ql6-wipe! (car (tls-event-data event)))27
(ql6-wipe! (cdr (tls-event-data event))))) events))29
(define (ql6-packet keys destination source number body token)30
(let* ((header (encode-packet-header 'initial destination source token number 431
(+ 16 (bytevector-length body)) length-width: 2))32
(payload (bytes-append body33
(make-bytevector (- 1200 16 (bytevector-length header) (bytevector-length body)) 0))))34
(seal-quic-packet keys 'initial destination source number payload token: token length-width: 2)))36
(define (ql6-with-client procedure (keys: (failure-limit quic-aes-gcm-failure-limit) (idle 30000) (start? #t)))37
(let ((client (make-quic-client (list #u8(113 49)) "example.test" (list (cons 1 (encode-varint idle)))38
(lambda (chain name) #f) destination-id: ql6-original local-id: ql6-client-id39
aead-failure-limit: failure-limit))40
(write (initial-keys ql6-original 'server)) (read (initial-keys ql6-original 'client)))41
(dynamic-wind42
(lambda () #t)43
(lambda ()44
(when start?45
(quic-start! client 0)46
(quic-take-datagrams! client 0))47
(procedure client write read))48
(lambda () (quic-abort! client) (discard-packet-keys! write) (discard-packet-keys! read)))))50
(define (ql6-server-packet keys number body (keys: (token #u8()) (source ql6-server-id)))51
(ql6-packet keys ql6-client-id source number body token))53
(define (ql6-ack! client keys ranges)54
(let* ((packets (quic-take-datagrams! client 0))55
(opened (and (pair? packets) (open-quic-packet (car packets) 0 8 keys -1)))56
(frames (if opened (decode-frames (opened-quic-packet-payload opened) 'initial 'client) '())))57
(assert-equal 1 (length packets))58
(assert-true (opened-quic-packet? opened))59
(assert-true (pair? frames))60
(when (pair? frames)61
(assert-equal 2 (quic-frame-type (car frames)))62
(when (= (quic-frame-type (car frames)) 2)63
(assert-equal ranges (frame-ref (car frames) 'ranges))))))65
(define (ql6-with-hello procedure)66
(let* ((key (ecdsa-p256-generate-keypair))67
(client (make-tls-client (list #u8(113 49)) "example.test" (list (cons 15 ql6-client-id))68
(lambda (chain name) (and (equal? chain (list #u8(48 1 0))) (cdr key)))))69
(tls-server (make-tls-server (list #u8(113 49))70
(list (cons 0 ql6-original) (cons 15 ql6-server-id)) (list #u8(48 1 0)) (car key)))71
(server (make-quic-server (list #u8(113 49)) '() (list #u8(48 1 0)) (car key)72
ql6-original ql6-client-id local-id: ql6-server-id))73
(write (initial-keys ql6-original 'client)) (read (initial-keys ql6-original 'server)))74
(dynamic-wind75
(lambda () #t)76
(lambda ()77
(tls-bind-peer! tls-server ql6-original ql6-client-id #f)78
(tls-start! client)79
(let ((hello (car (filter (lambda (event) (eq? (tls-event-kind event) 'crypto))80
(tls-take-events! client)))))81
(procedure (tls-event-data hello) tls-server server write read)))82
(lambda ()83
(tls-abort! client)84
(tls-abort! tls-server)85
(quic-abort! server)86
(discard-packet-keys! write)87
(discard-packet-keys! read)88
(ql6-wipe! (car key))))))90
(test-group "QUIC handshake header conformance"91
(test "ql6-conformance: server token cannot pin a CID or enter ACK history"92
(ql6-with-client93
(lambda (client write read)94
(quic-receive! client (ql6-server-packet write 0 #u8(1) token: #u8(9) source: ql6-other-id) 0)95
(assert-equal ql6-original (quic-peer-id client))96
(assert-equal '() (quic-take-datagrams! client 0))97
(quic-receive! client (ql6-server-packet write 1 #u8(1)) 0)98
(assert-false (quic-closed? client))99
(assert-equal ql6-server-id (quic-peer-id client))100
(ql6-ack! client read (list (cons 1 1))))))101
(test "ql6-conformance: forbidden token cannot consume the AEAD failure budget"102
(ql6-with-client103
(lambda (client write read)104
(let ((packet (ql6-server-packet write 0 #u8(1) token: #u8(9))))105
(quic-receive! client (flip-byte packet (- (bytevector-length packet) 1)) 0))106
(assert-false (quic-closed? client))107
(quic-receive! client (ql6-server-packet write 1 #u8(1)) 0)108
(assert-false (quic-failure client))109
(ql6-ack! client read (list (cons 1 1))))110
failure-limit: 1))111
(test "ql6-conformance: forbidden token cannot refresh idle activity"112
(ql6-with-client113
(lambda (client write read)114
(quic-receive! client (ql6-server-packet write 0 #u8(1) token: #u8(9)) 2000)115
(assert-equal '() (quic-take-datagrams! client 2000))116
(quic-tick! client 3000)117
(assert-true (quic-idle-expired? client))118
(assert-true (quic-closed? client))119
(assert-false (quic-failure client))120
(assert-equal '() (quic-take-datagrams! client 3000)))121
idle: 3000))122
(test "ql6-conformance: forbidden token cannot spend a closing replay slot"123
(ql6-with-client124
(lambda (client write read)125
(quic-receive! client (ql6-server-packet write 0 #u8(0)) 0)126
(quic-receive! client (ql6-server-packet write 1 #u8(0)) 0)127
(quic-close! client)128
(let ((packets (quic-take-datagrams! client 0)))129
(assert-equal 1 (length packets))130
(assert-true (quic-closing? client))131
(quic-receive! client (ql6-server-packet write 2 #u8(1) token: #u8(9)) 1000)132
(assert-equal '() (quic-take-datagrams! client 1000))133
(quic-receive! client (ql6-server-packet write 3 #u8(1)) 1000)134
(assert-equal packets (quic-take-datagrams! client 1000))))))135
(test "ql6-conformance: valid coalesced suffix survives a forbidden token prefix"136
(ql6-with-client137
(lambda (client write read)138
(quic-receive! client139
(bytes-append (ql6-server-packet write 0 #u8(1) token: #u8(9) source: ql6-other-id)140
(ql6-server-packet write 1 #u8(1))) 0)141
(assert-false (quic-closed? client))142
(assert-equal ql6-server-id (quic-peer-id client))143
(ql6-ack! client read (list (cons 1 1))))))144
(test "ql6-conformance: legacy session ID is PROTOCOL_VIOLATION in TLS and on wire"145
(ql6-with-hello146
(lambda (wire tls-server server write read)147
(let* ((hello (decode-client-hello wire))148
(changed (encode-client-hello (tls-client-hello-random hello) (make-bytevector 32 7)149
(tls-client-hello-cipher-suites hello) (tls-client-hello-extensions hello)))150
(failure (guard (exn (else exn)) (tls-input! tls-server 'initial changed) #f)))151
(assert-equal 10 (and (quic-error? failure) (quic-error-code failure)))152
(assert-true (tls-failed? tls-server))153
(let ((events (tls-take-events! tls-server)))154
(assert-equal '() events)155
(ql6-wipe-events! events))156
(quic-receive! server157
(ql6-packet write ql6-original ql6-client-id 0158
(encode-frames (list (make-quic-frame 6 (list (cons 'offset 0) (cons 'data changed))))159
'initial 'client) #u8()) 0)160
(assert-true (quic-closed? server))161
(assert-equal 10 (and (quic-error? (quic-failure server)) (quic-error-code (quic-failure server))))162
(let* ((packets (quic-take-datagrams! server 0))163
(opened (and (pair? packets) (open-quic-packet (car packets) 0 8 read -1)))164
(frames (if opened (decode-frames (opened-quic-packet-payload opened) 'initial 'server) '())))165
(assert-equal 1 (length packets))166
(assert-true (pair? frames))167
(when (pair? frames)168
(assert-equal 28 (quic-frame-type (car frames)))169
(when (= (quic-frame-type (car frames)) 28)170
(assert-equal 10 (frame-ref (car frames) 'error))171
(assert-equal #u8() (frame-ref (car frames) 'reason)))))))))172
(test "ql6-conformance: client Initial tokens remain accepted and ACKed"173
(ql6-with-hello174
(lambda (wire tls-server server write read)175
(quic-receive! server (ql6-packet write ql6-original ql6-client-id 0 #u8(1) #u8(9)) 0)176
(assert-false (quic-closed? server))177
(let* ((packets (quic-take-datagrams! server 0))178
(opened (and (pair? packets) (open-quic-packet (car packets) 0 8 read -1)))179
(frames (if opened (decode-frames (opened-quic-packet-payload opened) 'initial 'server) '())))180
(assert-equal 1 (length packets))181
(assert-true (opened-quic-packet? opened))182
(when opened (assert-equal #u8() (quic-header-token (opened-quic-packet-header opened))))183
(assert-true (pair? frames))184
(when (pair? frames)185
(assert-equal 2 (quic-frame-type (car frames)))186
(assert-equal (list (cons 0 0)) (frame-ref (car frames) 'ranges)))))))187
(test "ql6-conformance: empty legacy session ID still produces a server flight"188
(ql6-with-hello189
(lambda (wire tls-server server write read)190
(assert-equal #u8() (tls-client-hello-session-id (decode-client-hello wire)))191
(tls-input! tls-server 'initial wire)192
(assert-equal 'client-finished (tls-state tls-server))193
(let ((events (tls-take-events! tls-server)))194
(assert-true (any (lambda (event) (eq? (tls-event-kind event) 'crypto)) events))195
(ql6-wipe-events! events))))))197
(define (ql6-feed-tls! source target)198
(let ((events (tls-take-events! source)))199
(dynamic-wind200
(lambda () #t)201
(lambda ()202
(for-each203
(lambda (event)204
(when (eq? (tls-event-kind event) 'crypto)205
(tls-input! target (tls-event-level event) (tls-event-data event)))) events))206
(lambda () (ql6-wipe-events! events)))))208
(define (ql6-with-complete-tls procedure)209
(let* ((key (ecdsa-p256-generate-keypair))210
(client (make-tls-client (list #u8(113 49)) "example.test" (list (cons 15 ql6-client-id))211
(lambda (chain name) (and (equal? chain (list #u8(48 1 0))) (cdr key)))))212
(server (make-tls-server (list #u8(113 49))213
(list (cons 0 ql6-original) (cons 15 ql6-server-id)) (list #u8(48 1 0)) (car key))))214
(dynamic-wind215
(lambda () #t)216
(lambda ()217
(tls-bind-peer! client ql6-original ql6-server-id #f)218
(tls-bind-peer! server ql6-original ql6-client-id #f)219
(tls-start! client)220
(do ((i 0 (+ i 1))) ((= i 3))221
(ql6-feed-tls! client server)222
(ql6-feed-tls! server client))223
(assert-true (tls-complete? client))224
(assert-true (tls-complete? server))225
(procedure client server))226
(lambda () (tls-abort! client) (tls-abort! server) (ql6-wipe! (car key))))))228
(define (ql6-ticket lifetime (keys: (ticket #u8(42)) (extensions '())))229
(encode-handshake 4230
(bytes-append (tls-uint lifetime 4) (tls-uint 0 4)231
(tls-vector #u8() 1 0 255) (tls-vector ticket 2 0 65535) (encode-extensions extensions))))233
(define (ql6-short-server-hello! client initial-write initial-read)234
(let* ((key (ecdsa-p256-generate-keypair))235
(server (make-tls-server (list #u8(113 49))236
(list (cons 0 ql6-original) (cons 15 ql6-server-id)) (list #u8(48 1 0)) (car key)))237
(events '()) (write #f) (read #f))238
(dynamic-wind239
(lambda () #t)240
(lambda ()241
(quic-start! client 0)242
(let* ((packet (car (quic-take-datagrams! client 0)))243
(opened (open-quic-packet packet 0 8 initial-read -1))244
(frames (decode-frames (opened-quic-packet-payload opened) 'initial 'client))245
(crypto (car (filter (lambda (frame) (= (quic-frame-type frame) 6)) frames))))246
(assert-equal 0 (frame-ref crypto 'offset))247
(tls-bind-peer! server ql6-original ql6-client-id #f)248
(tls-input! server 'initial (frame-ref crypto 'data)))249
(set! events (tls-take-events! server))250
(let* ((hello (car (filter (lambda (event)251
(and (eq? (tls-event-kind event) 'crypto)252
(eq? (tls-event-level event) 'initial))) events)))253
(secret (tls-event-data254
(car (filter (lambda (event)255
(and (eq? (tls-event-kind event) 'secrets)256
(eq? (tls-event-level event) 'handshake))) events)))))257
(set! write (traffic-keys (cdr secret)))258
(set! read (traffic-keys (car secret)))259
(ql6-wipe-events! events)260
;; Protect each PN once: no trimming/resealing of an existing flight.261
(let ((packet262
(seal-quic-packet initial-write 'initial ql6-client-id ql6-server-id 0263
(encode-frames264
(list (make-quic-frame 6 (list (cons 'offset 0) (cons 'data (tls-event-data hello)))))265
'initial 'server))))266
(assert-true (< (bytevector-length packet) 1200))267
(quic-receive! client packet 0))268
(quic-receive! client269
(seal-quic-packet write 'handshake ql6-client-id ql6-server-id 0 #u8(1)) 0)270
(let* ((packets (quic-take-datagrams! client 0))271
(handshake (filter (lambda (packet)272
(eq? (quic-header-kind (decode-packet-header packet 0 8)) 'handshake))273
packets))274
(opened (and (pair? handshake) (open-quic-packet (car handshake) 0 8 read -1)))275
(frames (if opened (decode-frames (opened-quic-packet-payload opened) 'handshake 'client) '())))276
(assert-equal 1 (length handshake))277
(assert-true (opened-quic-packet? opened))278
(assert-true (pair? frames))279
(when (pair? frames)280
(assert-equal 2 (quic-frame-type (car frames)))281
(when (= (quic-frame-type (car frames)) 2)282
(assert-equal (list (cons 0 0)) (frame-ref (car frames) 'ranges))))283
(assert-false (quic-closed? client)))))284
(lambda ()285
(when write (discard-packet-keys! write))286
(when read (discard-packet-keys! read))287
(ql6-wipe-events! events)288
(tls-abort! server)289
(ql6-wipe! (car key))))))291
(test-group "QUIC receive and ticket tolerance"292
(test "ql6-tolerance: short authenticated server PING is pinned and ACKed"293
(ql6-with-client294
(lambda (client write read)295
(let ((packet (seal-quic-packet write 'initial ql6-client-id ql6-server-id 0 #u8(1))))296
(assert-true (< (bytevector-length packet) 1200))297
(quic-receive! client packet 0))298
(assert-equal ql6-server-id (quic-peer-id client))299
(assert-false (quic-failure client))300
(ql6-ack! client read (list (cons 0 0))))))301
(test "ql6-tolerance: short ServerHello enables independently protected Handshake ACKs"302
(ql6-with-client ql6-short-server-hello! start?: #f))303
(test "ql6-tolerance: discarded overlong ticket lifetimes preserve completed TLS"304
(ql6-with-complete-tls305
(lambda (client server)306
(tls-input! client 'application307
(bytes-append (ql6-ticket 604801) (ql6-ticket 4294967295)))308
(let ((wire (ql6-ticket 4294967295)))309
(do ((i 0 (+ i 1))) ((= i (bytevector-length wire)))310
(tls-input! client 'application (bytevector-copy wire i (+ i 1)))))311
(tls-input! client 'application (ql6-ticket 0))312
(assert-true (tls-complete? client))313
(assert-false (tls-failed? client))314
(assert-equal '() (tls-take-events! client)))))315
(test "ql6-tolerance: server still discards a short client Initial before ACK history"316
(ql6-with-hello317
(lambda (wire tls-server server write read)318
(let ((packet (seal-quic-packet write 'initial ql6-original ql6-client-id 0 #u8(1))))319
(assert-true (< (bytevector-length packet) 1200))320
(quic-receive! server packet 0))321
(assert-equal '() (quic-take-datagrams! server 0))322
(assert-false (quic-closed? server))323
(quic-receive! server (ql6-packet write ql6-original ql6-client-id 1 #u8(1) #u8()) 0)324
(let* ((packets (quic-take-datagrams! server 0))325
(opened (and (pair? packets) (open-quic-packet (car packets) 0 8 read -1)))326
(frames (if opened (decode-frames (opened-quic-packet-payload opened) 'initial 'server) '())))327
(assert-equal 1 (length packets))328
(assert-true (pair? frames))329
(when (pair? frames)330
(assert-equal 2 (quic-frame-type (car frames)))331
(when (= (quic-frame-type (car frames)) 2)332
(assert-equal (list (cons 1 1)) (frame-ref (car frames) 'ranges))))))))333
(test "ql6-tolerance: overlong lifetime does not bypass malformed ticket parsing"334
(ql6-with-complete-tls335
(lambda (client server)336
(assert-error (tls-input! client 'application (ql6-ticket 4294967295 ticket: #u8())))337
(assert-true (tls-failed? client))338
(assert-equal 0 (tls-retained-input-bytes client))339
(assert-equal '() (tls-take-events! client)))))340
(test "ql6-tolerance: zero and seven day tickets with unknown extensions remain discardable"341
(ql6-with-complete-tls342
(lambda (client server)343
(tls-input! client 'application344
(bytes-append (ql6-ticket 0) (ql6-ticket 604800 extensions: (list (cons 1234 #u8(7 8))))))345
(assert-true (tls-complete? client))346
(assert-true (tls-complete? server))347
(assert-equal '() (tls-take-events! client))))))